Tue 7 Jun 2011
My Identity Crisis: Why can’t I be more than one thing on the web?
Posted by Regan Wolfrom under General Updates
[9] Comments
I don’t use Twitter much; I guess that means I don’t use it well. The same can be said for my blog and my personal website (which aren’t particularly connected to each other). I’m pretty quiet on the web, and I think that may be detrimental.
But I can’t just start using everything more, because I have a problem. There’s too many me’s on the web.
I’m one of the co-founders of Windsoc, and I have several web projects aside from that. I’ve done quite a bit of consulting in the past, and I still do the odd one today. I’ve also dabbled in politics, having run for office once and spent many hours on issues that I feel are important, such as youth recreation and city planning. And I’m a part-time writer of speculative fiction, spending around 0.1 hours a week on it and seeing my literary career advance at the same rate as the snows of Kilimanjaro. And then there’s that television series I was working on…
So which one of these “hats” do I wear on Twitter? I worry about annoying followers by talking about the wrong things, so I generally say nothing at all. My personal blog has always been political, so I don’t feel it makes sense to start talking about startups or technology or programming. And there are many things I just can’t say on the Windsoc Blog, since I’m not the only one involved in this venture.
I can’t imagine I’m the only person with this problem. I’ve thought about ways of fixing it, from having multiple Twitter accounts, websites and blogs, to simply categorizing entries with hashtags or other devices and accepting that some people will just find me too noisy. But I think there needs to be a rethink here, a new way of segregating aspects of an identity.
We’ve played around with this at Windsoc for a while, with the idea of creating circles and channels to organize and focus an individual’s online contributions. Such a system interfaces well with Facebook, but fails miserably on Twitter because there is no private messaging within the timeline. Now if direct messages showed up in the timeline and didn’t always send an e-mail, things would be much different and the Windsoc Social Client would probably be out there for people to use.
Maybe something can be done with Facebook now, a way of constantly segregating your feeds and posts based on your current “aspect”. But would anyone really do that, or could they use the Pages feature to similar effect? Or do we need a new service that is designed from the start to handle multiple aspects? Or should I throw one on Twitter, one on LinkedIn, etc., and use a social aggregator to monitor and manage them all?
I don’t have the answer. Not yet, anyway. And I wish I did. This identity crisis is deepening with every passing day.
Discuss this post on Hacker News
9 Responses to “ My Identity Crisis: Why can’t I be more than one thing on the web? ”
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
[...] – My Identity Crisis: Why can’t I be more than one thing on the web? [...]
At one time I was maintaining several blogs, for different matters (one for my art & poetry stuff, another for my hacking adventures, another for more professional matters).
I understand your dilemna.
It still makes sense to me to compartmentalize some of these things, since I will different readers/followers interested in one aspect, and not another. I have various sites for my art, my poetry, my software, my business…I have a one, single-page site that serves as a hub (linked in this comment).
But, if you’re looking for a social networking site that allows for distinct aspects, check out diaspora (it even uses that terminology, “aspects” for different threads/groups). https://joindiaspora.com/
Ha ! I have similar issues… Hopefully someone will comment on solutions. I’m holding off blog and identi.ca mostly for this reason.
I don’t even know what language to use on social networks between native French and ubiquitous English. Sigh…
Probably the best point on the web – ever. I could not agree more. I’ve online community managed for over a decade. I’m also a writer. I’m involved in social media. Somewhere along the line Klout determined I was influential in – Klout. I’m also a professional chef with over 30 years cooking experience. Did I mention I’m an expert medical and pharmaceutical terminologist? If I want a job, do people think I have split personalities due to the confines of the web, or do they see me for the accomplished person I am? I don’t know because the limitation is you seem to only be able to be one thing online – SPOT ON PIECE – thank you very much! I’m adding to my blog roll!
that’s also a problem to me,,
but my decision is a little different,
i tried to get familiar with each site,
then post different posts,
my aim is to store them and i can find them anytime i need to refer,,
with such experience,,i think i need a powerfull tool,,
Word. Especially with like so many sites using facebook or twitter for logins or comments.
Start thinking about what you want to see instead of what you don’t
If you want to come up with the answer, that is.